The State of Oil and Gas: December 15, 2021

Natural gas prices are at $3.88/MMBtu, having hit a low of $3.66 on December 6, and a high of $5.45 on November 26. Rig counts are at 576, up 13. Slow and steady is great! Gas storage numbers are from December 3, but seem to be trending toward the five year average. With some warm weather in the near-term forecast, we could see gas prices drop closer to $3.00 in the next week or so.

A lot of people that I talk with wonder whether oil and gas are going to be needed in the future, and based off what you see in the news and on social media you can be forgiven for thinking that they won’t be. However, the more rational number crunchers at the United States Energy Information Agency (a government agency, not some oddly named private organization) show that in 30 years the amount of energy provided by solar generation will only make up 20% of our energy needs. If you take a close look at that graph, you will notice that the total amount of energy produced by other sources (including wind) will be greater than the total amount we use today. So while solar generation will grow, it’s not going to actually cut in to oil and gas. Combined with wind it probably will, but not enough to make oil and gas properties obsolete. Don’t sell your oil and gas mineral rights just because you think renewables are going to take over energy production.

A Reuters article stating that drilling activity will have to pick up next year.

President Biden is putting pressure on OPEC+ to increase oil production. He should be putting that pressure on American producers. However, he’s trying to look like a good environmentalist at home, and after his federal land development ban back in the first part of this year he needs to not flip-flop, so he’s not. Seems a little short-sighted to me. Additional drilling here in America would put Americans to work and reduce the cost of gasoline and electricity. There are a lot of wins there.

West Virginia’s legislature really messed things up when they changed the law on how to value natural gas production for taxation purposes. There’s some talk of throwing the law out completely and starting over from scratch.

COVID was the driving factor in last year’s ridiculously low natural gas prices. We haven’t had to mention COVID for a few months, but there’s a new variant emerging in South Africa that has the stock market spooked, and that’s usually a sign that it’s serious. So keep an eye on the Omicron variant of COVID. UPDATE on Dec. 15: Omicron has emerged as a well publicized concern, but it’s full effects are not yet known.

The Biden administration has ordered the release of oil from the Strategic Oil Reserve. This will drive down the price of gasoline, at least temporarily. Drilling is the only thing that will drive the price down long term. UPDATE on Dec 14: The release was supposed to be coordinated with releases by other countries, which have not complied so far.

There is an interesting court case ongoing in Ohio. It pits a farm that is owned by an agricultural easement against a pipeline company. The pipeline is trying to use eminent domain to force a right of way onto the farm. The farm is arguing that the agricultural easement protects it from all uses other than agricultural. Interestingly, a nearby city tried to use the farm for a sewer pipeline at one point, and was denied. Also interestingly, the State of Ohio Department of Agriculture actually owns the agricultural easement, but is not helping to defend this suit in spite of the fact that it has defended other agricultural easements. There are other agricultural easements in Ohio, and their “owners” are watching.

Here’s an article that makes the argument for why a release of oil from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve is not going to drive gasoline prices down.

Producers have been using up their Drilled but UnCompleted (DUC) wells, but the supply is dwindling and at some point producers have to lean more toward drilling new wells. When that happens, profits will drop. How that plays out will be interesting to watch.

Crude oil drops below $65/bbl, but it’s not likely to last. Take predictions with the usual grain of salt.

The State of West Virginia ran a budget surplus last month, in large part because of high oil and gas prices. Now remember, State-officials-in-charge-of-spending, that we have lean times coming up. Put that money into a rainy day fund, because if there’s one thing we know it’s that oil and gas prices go down after they go up.

We’re exporting more gas, with deliveries to LNG facilities hitting a record high in November.

RBNEnergy explains that we are running out of pipeline capacity in the Appalachian region (West Virginia, Ohio, and PA) even if the Mountain Valley Pipeline gets built. MVP will make a difference, but only for a short period of time. Trouble is, I don’t see new pipelines getting built after ACP got the ax. The same problems that plagued it and still plague MVP will be problems for every other pipeline project. That’s going to lead to reduced royalty payments for West Virginia mineral owners, and higher natural gas prices for everybody.

Wegmans is shifting its trucking fleet from diesel to compressed natural gas.

Weirton, WV and the Brownlee Well Pad

The citizens of Weirton, WV are rallying against a well pad proposed by SWN. It will be located on a 300 acre tract of land, which is awfully big, but it’s also awfully close to some retail shopping and other businesses, and close enough to some residential areas that I can understand their concern. See maps below.

300 acre tract where well will be located
Permitted location of Brownlee well pad

The usual concerns my clients have expressed in the past have been about light and noise from the drilling rig, and dust and road damage from the trucks.

Those residential areas to the north and to the east of the Brownlee well pad will definitely be affected by the light, and even to some extent by the noise. Those drilling rigs make a lot of noise at times. The lights are the main complaint I’ve heard, though. When they’re drilling, the rig is like a high powered, all-white-light Christmas tree. The lights are so bright it can make it hard to sleep at night.

The good news is that there is quick access to the highway so the trucks won’t spend a lot of time on surface roads. I would want to know which roads they will be using, and make sure SWN keeps those truckers in control. One of the main complaints I hear is that truckers get too comfortable with their routes and start really flying along. It can be heart stopping when a big truck like that comes barreling past going the other way on a sharp curve, and barely staying in its lane.

SWN and other oil and gas companies must do a better job of working with their neighbors than they have previously. If the Atlantic Coast Pipeline had been a better neighbor it might have been able to complete its project, and definitely would have been a lot closer to its original deadlines. The days of the Wild, Wild, West in oil and gas drilling are gone. Oil and gas companies no longer get to bully landowners the way they used to, even though they still try to.

We really hope that SWN works with its neighbors in this case.