DUCs Have Been Coming Online Already

This is a fascinating article on the Reuters website.  It says that some oil companies have already been completing and producing oil from their Drilled but UnCompleted (DUC) wells.  The majority of the work has been in Texas, near the oil refineries, which allows the producer to realize a price close to benchmark prices.  Some of the production has been farther away though, as some companies have their oil production hedged at high enough prices to make production profitable.

This is interesting because it means that some of the oversupply that people have been factoring into their calculations has already been used up.  We may see a bump up in oil prices based off this information.

The question becomes, are some gas producers doing the same thing?  Antero Resources here in the Appalachian Basin has all of their gas production hedged at prices high enough to make a profit.  They also have some DUCs.  Are they completing and producing their DUCs?  Are other companies?  If they are, is the price of gas going to go up sooner than expected?  It’s hard to tell, but we sure do hope so.

West Virginia Needs This Kind of Thing

Primus Green Energy has announced that they are building a gas to liquids plant somewhere in the Marcellus Shale region.  The actual location has not been announced.  Since the plant is supposed to be up and running in 2017 it’s safe to assume that the location has already been decided.  If it hasn’t our governor, legislators, and county officials should be contacting Primus to see what they can do to get it located inside this State. Shoot, gas producers should be knocking their door down.  The plant will be able to use pretty much any type of gas that comes out of the ground and we have a real oversupply of wet gasses to the extent that wet gasses are costing producers money.

That said, Primus Green Energy hasn’t put together a commercial scale plant yet. They currently have one pre-commercial demonstration plant located in New Jersey.  Scaling up to commercial sizes may pose some difficulties.  However, the technology seems to be viable, and the company doesn’t seem to be a fly-by-night operation, so it seems that taking a bit of a risk would be worth it.

Perhaps the most interesting aspect of their technology is that it appears that it can be done on small scales.  There are currently only five gas to liquids plants operating globally, with four proposed, according to the EIA.  Most of them are pretty large.  The one pictured in the link above is certainly not large.  Perhaps this is the kind of plant that could be developed on a local basis with smaller capital funding costs.

Ohio’s Clinton Sandstone Produces Oil From Horizontal Fracturing

EnerVest is drilling horizontal wells down to the Clinton formation in Ohio.  The Clinton produces oil, but not in huge quantities.  It’s enough to make a profit though, even in today’s bad oil market.  The wells cost just under $2 million, and return between $7 million and $10 million.  That’s a pretty good ROI.

Cunningham Energy is doing something similar with the Big Injun and the Weir Sand formations here in West Virginia.  They’re not drilling a lot right now, and the market isn’t good for oil right now, but if they’re able to keep the lights on until oil prices start to come back up they should be in a really good position.

Speaking of oil prices, they’re back over $41/bbl today.  We don’t see those prices being sustainable over the long term but if the Saudis are able to get Iran to agree to a production freeze at any level, maybe they will be.  Maybe.

Saudia Arabia and Oil Prices

This article at the English side of Al-Arabiya has a different take on Saudi Arabia’s motiviations and goals in keeping oil production up.  While the site most likely has a pro-Arab stance, the article seems to be worth reading.  Most sites have a pro-something-or-other stance anyways, so it’s probably handy to know beforehand what that things they’re proponents of is.  It also provides a good overview of some of the numbers involved in the Saudi budget and oil production.

State of Oil and Gas: March 2016

Ah, the joys of predicting oil and gas prices.  I don’t think anyone at the end of January would have predicted that oil would have hit $40/bbl in mid-March, a mere six weeks later.  Won’t stop anybody from trying to predict future prices, of course.  We’ve given up on it here a Nuttall Legal.  Here are some the articles we’ve read about it in the last month.

It’s looking like oil prices are going to be low for a long time.  During this period of high production by, well, everyone, stockpiles of oil have risen to 1 billion barrels.  To put that into perspective, the world uses about 94 million barrels of oil each day.  (That’s more of a guesstimate than a precise number, but it’s close.)  World use has grown by about a million barrels per day each year over the last few years, meaning that in 2014 we were using about 93 million barrels per day, in 2013 we were using about 92 million barrels per day, and so forth.  Those are rough numbers, of course. Here are the official EIA numbers.  To be perfectly honest, nobody really knows exactly how much oil the world uses because reporting is imperfect and there’s a black market that’s unreported.  However, based off what we know, oil production would have to completely stop for about 10 days for us to work through the stockpiles of oil we know we have.  A halt in production like that would require the kind of worldwide catastrophe that would make us not care whether oil was being produced.  What we’re getting at here is that once there is a freeze or a cut in oil production it’s going to be a long time before the surplus oil will be used up.  That’s going to keep oil prices down for a lot longer than some people think.  We’ll say it once again, go ahead and plan that great American road trip for this summer.

Southwestern Energy is not drilling any new wells this year.  That will definitely contribute to a decline in gas production.  However, gas production in the Marcellus shale has been 2 billion cubic feet more than anticipated.  This because of increased efficiency by drilling rigs and new pipeline being opened.  It’s still an overall decrease in production, but not by nearly the amount anticipated.

For another perspective on oil prices, read this Foreign Policy article.  In it, Robert Mosbacher, Jr. hints that by 2017 we are going to see a massive shortage of oil and a corresponding increase in oil prices.  He also says that we’re going to see immense boom-bust cycles coming up.  He thinks that the Saudis should have done what they could to keep oil prices in the $40-$60 range.  At that range fracking would have been marginally productive, with some areas being economically producible and others not.  He says that the Saudis have not accepted the fact that they are no longer the world’s swing producer.  It’s hard to fault his reasoning.  Looking at the numbers he floats, it would take about six months (roughly) to burn through the 1 billion barrels of oil that are now stockpiled around the world.  By 2017, which is when he suggests that oil production will drop off enough to start to be felt, we may have quite a bit more in the way of stockpiles.  But at a burn rate of 5 million barrels per day you can burn through 1.85 billion barrels of oil in a year.  Just another point of view to think about.

This Reuters article points out one of the reasons that oil and gas prices are going to be low for a while.  Frackers are using new techniques to increase production from new wells.  They are decreasing the distance between frack stages and clusters, increasing the amount of frack fluid, increasing the amount of sand, and moving high speed rigs to the sweet spots in the respective plays.  All of these things bring production from each well up, and consequently bring the cost per barrel or MCF down.  Increased efficiency means that fracking can be profitable at lower energy prices.  The Saudis unleashed the beast and they don’t have any way to bring it back.

We’ve also reached a national low.  There were fewer drilling rigs operating in the United States then there have been since 1940.  We expect to see that number get even lower before it starts to increase.

This article from Seeking Alpha says that oil prices aren’t going to climb above $50/bbl until the end of 2017.

This article from fuelfix.com says that it’s not as important to drillers what the price of oil (or, presumably, gas) actually is.  It’s more important to have the money to drill.  And apparently banks are still willing to finance oil drillers to a certain extent.  It seems that some gas drillers are also a good bet.  Range Resources has a $4 billion line of credit, and have only used $95 million of it.  Even better, the borrowing base won’t be redetermined until May of 2017.  That’s a lot of money to keep the lights on, and it’s good for a long time.  We’re expecting gas prices to start to recover by then.

On the other hand, it looks like gas prices are going to stay down for at least most of this year.  That article points out that it’s likely to be a mild summer, gas storage is above the five year average, and production hasn’t really slowed down much yet.  Of course, that doesn’t take into account the LNG exports that have begun and the natural increase in gas usage from economic growth.  The catastrophic drop in prices the article predicts are unlikely, but a recovery is also unlikely.

 

 

Interactive Pipeline Map

I’m a sucker for maps, and when you combine my job with one of my other interests, I get sucked right in.  This map is an interactive map that you can zoom in on that shows all the pipelines in the United States.  It doesn’t show the exact routes they take, but you get a good feel for where there is a lot of oil and gas being moved around and where there isn’t.

Stone Energy in Trouble

We have a few clients who have leased with Stone Energy over the years.  Some have been drilled on, others are still waiting.  Those who are waiting may still be waiting a while.  Stone Energy announced that it has borrowed $385 million dollars on its line of credit.  That’s the last of it, too.  Stone has to keep the lights on with that money or it will have to declare bankruptcy.  Seeing as how Stone lost $1 billion dollars last year, and we don’t expect gas prices to move up much until the end of 2016 or the beginning of 2017, we’re not terribly confident that $385 million dollars will keep Stone going until things get better.  It will be interesting to see what creative techniques Stone’s financial and legal advisers come up with to keep operating.  For the sake of our clients who have signed leases with Stone we hope that they can pull it off.  Of course, if they don’t some larger company will just move in and buy up all those leases at fire sale prices during bankruptcy proceedings or when Stone puts them on the market to drum up cash.  The leases won’t just disappear.

CNG and LNG in Fleet Vehicles

One use for natural gas is to power cars, trucks, buses, and other vehicles.  Right now the majority of compressed natural gas vehicles are fleet vehicles, due to a lack of infrastructure.  At one point in the past, some infrastructure was being built out for CNG, but when gasoline prices dropped people started moving away from CNG.  Gasoline prices have again dropped, but interest in CNG doesn’t seem to be disappearing.  Businesses and governments realize that this drop in prices isn’t going to last forever.  It will probably last a few years, but there is also the potential for a sudden jump in prices if something catastrophic happened; say a war in the Middle East (who could imagine?) or a hurricane in the Gulf Coast (ditto).

Companies like Clean Energy are providing some of that infrastructure.  So far it’s only to fleet vehicles, but someday the infrastructure will expand to us, the consumers.  The sooner the better.  CNG burns cleaner than gasoline and is cheaper to boot.  If the infrastructure is built out and the cars are manufactured, it will happen.

Also, USPS is adding CNG and LNG trucks to its fleet.  The more the merrier.

 

West Virginia Nuisance Lawsuits Against Oil and Gas Companies Sent Back to Mediation

There are around 200 people who have filed nuisance lawsuits against two oil and gas companies here in West Virginia.  Judge Moats has ordered them back to mediation, telling the parties that fixing the problem is worth more than money.  The parties previously went to mediation.  Perhaps having the judge encourage the parties to settle will help mediation move along a bit.  We think Judge Moats’ words were well chosen.  They could be interpreted to hint that the judge is leaning either way.  Perhaps it’s better to say that neither party can say that the judge is leaning toward their own side.

In related news, we have heard through the grapevine that SB 508, which would have severely limited the ability of landowners to bring nuisance lawsuits against any company operating nearby, has been defeated.  It’s a little too soon to say for sure that’s the case, but the word out of Charleston is that the House Judiciary is unlikely to pass the bill out to the full House.

Legislative Update, March 1, 2016

We may be a day early to report the death of this year’s forced pooling bill, but the rumors coming out of Charleston and the news articles we’ve read sound promising.  Good for McGeehan and everyone else who has worked to defeat this bill.  Maybe next year they’ll come up with something that makes it easier for oil and gas companies to put together drilling units, but without taking away private property rights.  Eminent domain is one of a few things the Founding Fathers got wrong.

The other good thing we’ve seen is that the bill which would have allowed pipeline companies to enter private property without permission if they were surveying for a proposed pipeline easement has been killed.  The Senate voted it down by a margin of 2-1.  Those are good numbers against a bad bill.